tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post6506487645511974633..comments2024-03-15T12:58:41.305+05:30Comments on Bored Cricket Crazy Indians (BCC!) - play with cricket: Mountains out of molehillsGaurav Sethi http://www.blogger.com/profile/04330224127597873431noreply@blogger.comBlogger39125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-63186095080664672572009-10-03T09:51:36.393+05:302009-10-03T09:51:36.393+05:30Wasim,
"England prevailed over South Africa ...Wasim,<br /><br />"England prevailed over South Africa because they had the bowling,Smith is some one who can tear apart any attack in the world.It was a close contest on a true batting pitch. You cannot blame the bowlers there."<br /><br />And the pitch that India played Pakistan was what exactly?<br /><br />"You also forgot to mention that India was on it's way to concede 300 runs against Australia in its match against Australia."<br /><br />Australia was also on its way to win comfortably against Pakistan, at 140/2. And India may have be on its way to do anything, the point is, we will never know, will we?<br /><br />"The problem is there but if we want to bury our heads in sand then I guess it will never get resolved."<br /><br />The problem is of form, nothing more nothing less. It is as exaggerated as India's perceived weakness against the short ball or the supposed Dhoni-Sehwag rift during the T20 WC in England.<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-89355295273287201452009-10-03T09:46:19.003+05:302009-10-03T09:46:19.003+05:30K,
"I would think a bowler who is playing at...K,<br /><br />"I would think a bowler who is playing at the highest level would realize how to alter his length based on the conditions, but apparently they dont."<br /><br />Thats true.. Otherwise, why would we be making such a song and dance about it? Why is it that India continue to attract the poor travelers tag ? And why is it that we are considered to e poor players of the short ball?<br /><br />If it was a matter of getting up and hitting the right lines, can you imagine how totally monotonous cricket would be?<br /><br />And no, I am not suggesting that the BCCI schedule cock up is solely responsible for the exit. <br /><br />What I am saying is that it could have played its part. And what I have been emphasizing on is that India are notorious to start slow every time they come from a break. Couple that with form and there is a fairly plausible reason for our underperformance. <br /><br />But the notion that we lack the ability or that bowling is a weakness is laughable.<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-58741093751102981812009-10-03T09:42:18.322+05:302009-10-03T09:42:18.322+05:30ek,
I cannot argue for Mr Panicker.. That is some...ek,<br /><br />I cannot argue for Mr Panicker.. That is something you will have to do on his blog.. But the point he raises is a valid one.<br /><br />Looking back at the tapes of the 2007 T20 WC, the lengths are noticably different. Is it a coincidence that the T20 WC came at the back of a long tour of England? Or is it because we were playing cricket and were in mid season form and therefore could adjust our game better as compared to now, when we are basically starting cold?<br /><br />As far as he Dravid selection goes, I had called it a mistake the moment the probables were announced and I have found no reason to change my mind.<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-33947702406258027562009-10-02T12:01:15.224+05:302009-10-02T12:01:15.224+05:30Homer
There is a huge difference of perception he...Homer<br /><br />There is a huge difference of perception here, you overlooked an important fact that India's batting ineptitude was caused by some fine bowling.<br /><br />England prevailed over South Africa because they had the bowling,Smith is some one who can tear apart any attack in the world.It was a close contest on a true batting pitch. You cannot blame the bowlers there.<br /><br />You also forgot to mention that India was on it's way to concede 300 runs against Australia in its match against Australia.<br /><br />The problem is there but if we want to bury our heads in sand then I guess it will never get resolved.Wasimhttp://www.cricketfiles.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-43772947364236002982009-10-02T11:37:53.236+05:302009-10-02T11:37:53.236+05:30Disclaimer:In my book, Cup winning is more importa...Disclaimer:<b>In my book, Cup winning is more important than ranking. It is just my opinion and other fans may choose to disagree; which is OK with me.</b><br />One consequence of my thinking is that bilateral/tri-series are grounds for blooding/grooming cricketers to win the World Cups/Champion trophy.<br />For me, the mountain is India's poor performances in these tourneys post-2003. The molehill is excellent performances home and away in bilateral series in the last 12 months.adverbinnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-2133004897101508672009-10-02T11:24:37.834+05:302009-10-02T11:24:37.834+05:30Right Homer, the Indian bowlers werent able to hit...Right Homer, the Indian bowlers werent able to hit the right line and length due to a scheduling blunder by the BCCI, is that it? And that they couldnt adjust to the different conditions in SA after playing in Sri lanka, whereas NZ actually did well because they bowled crap in srilanka, but it was good enough in SA? Thats priceless.<br /><br />I would think a bowler who is playing at the highest level would realize how to alter his length based on the conditions, but apparently they dont.<br /><br />And as I mentioned, the victories over England and Srilanka actually masked our weakness, and these were brought to fore in the CT, were brought to fore in the T20 WC. So I dont think I can console myself by saying India beat England 5-0 and Srilanka 4-1, so they cant be such a bad team after all. <br /><br />Quoting a line from your response 'And if the bowling is not penetrative, then it requires all the help it can get from the surface'.......Any surface cannot help a bowler if he repeatedly bowls short and wide outside the off stump, leaking runs behind point. In short, if he bowls without skill.Knoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-76938901536868673212009-10-02T11:04:27.170+05:302009-10-02T11:04:27.170+05:30Not too much short stuff after the first couple of...Not too much short stuff after the first couple of overs, isn't it? I'm still curious as to why he thinks you're supposed to bowl a shorter length in Sri Lanka. There's always some movement in the air and/or off the pitch there, especially in the second innings of day-night games. Also, if you're supposed to bowl fuller in South Africa then was there really a need for Dravid to "negotiate" short-pitch bowling?<br /><br />Here's the thing. There is always one kind of bowling that will work better than anything else. It's called hitting the top of off. Now, Parnell may have bowled quite a few bad deliveries but he got a number of batsmen out bowled and LBW. Some of his dismissals were off the slower ball too. You don't take 11 wickets in 3 games if you've bowled badly.Mahekhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09911423802697065635noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-66343282122277936622009-10-02T10:32:21.342+05:302009-10-02T10:32:21.342+05:30Mahek,
With respect, I dont think Mr Panicker is ...Mahek,<br /><br />With respect, I dont think Mr Panicker is way off the mark here<br /><br /><a href="http://www.cricinfo.com/iccct2009/engine/match/415273.html?bowler=50121;innings=1;view=commentary" rel="nofollow">South Africa v Sri Lanka </a><br /><br /><a href="http://www.cricinfo.com/iccct2009/engine/match/415275.html?bowler=50121;innings=1;view=commentary" rel="nofollow">South Africa v New Zealand </a><br /><br /><a href="http://www.cricinfo.com/iccct2009/engine/match/415280.html?bowler=50121;innings=1;view=commentary" rel="nofollow">South Africa v England </a><br /><br /><a href="http://www.cricinfo.com/compaq/engine/current/match/403382.html?innings=1;view=commentary" rel="nofollow">India v New Zealand </a><br /><br /><a href="http://www.cricinfo.com/compaq/engine/current/match/403383.html?innings=2;page=1;view=commentary" rel="nofollow">Sri Lanka v India </a><br /><br /><a href="http://www.cricinfo.com/compaq/engine/current/match/403381.html?innings=1;view=commentary" rel="nofollow">Sri Lanka v India </a><br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-82556681905869267092009-10-02T10:07:36.942+05:302009-10-02T10:07:36.942+05:30I'm also curious as to what return series Pani...I'm also curious as to what return series Panicker is talking about. Sri Lanka's tour of India is part of the FTP. They won't be touring India for another series until after 2012. Just another example of a so-called wise man indulging in intellectual masturbation and showering his wisdom on his loyal subjects.Mahekhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09911423802697065635noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-69225439396561746182009-10-02T10:04:55.301+05:302009-10-02T10:04:55.301+05:30Bowl touch shorter in Sri Lanka? Gee I wonder what...Bowl touch shorter in Sri Lanka? Gee I wonder what Vaas was doing all those years bowling full and swinging the ball.<br /><br />Kiwis bowl a fuller length? When?<br /><br />England and Australia bowl fuller in England? Yeah right!!!<br /><br />Wayne Parnell bowling short? Have I been watching different matches as Mr. Panicker?<br /><br />Didn't the selectors panic when the Indian batsmen were "found out" against the short ball in England? Didn't they pick Dravid because he handled the short ball better (supposedly)? So they were expecting bouncier tracks, no?<br /><br />Resting players for big series? But didn't they just come off a two-month layoff? How much more rest do players need? They can always not play in the IPL like some of the Aussies, isn't it?<br /><br />Everyone knows there isn't a lot of emphasis on long-term results in Indian cricket. But to make up ridiculous examples to prove one's point is pathetic. There is a bowling coach and it's his job to ensure the bowlers know where to bowl. Last time I checked, bowling two feet outside offstump was a cardinal sin on ANY pitch. And I'm not even getting into the crap Harbhajan has been dishing out for months. It's an insult to an offspinner if he keeps getting cut behind point for four.Mahekhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09911423802697065635noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-52507339837121989672009-10-02T09:29:40.394+05:302009-10-02T09:29:40.394+05:30Aditya,
I am with you :)
Cheers,Aditya,<br /><br />I am with you :)<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06387483505008411160noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-41792823867608166422009-10-02T09:29:12.550+05:302009-10-02T09:29:12.550+05:30K,
Lets talk death bowl bowling first. If a bowli...K,<br /><br />Lets talk death bowl bowling first. If a bowling attack is so penetrative, the death over scenario does not arise at all - vide our performance against WI. And if the bowling is not penetrative, then it requires all the help it can get from the surface.<br /><br />For all the talk of how ineffective our bowling attack is, we beat England 5-0 at home. And their pace attack wasn't too different from the one they are fielding here. And didn't they lost 6-1 to Australia?<br /><br />When South Africa beat Australia in the CB series in Australia. At that time, all the talk was about how complete the Protea attack was. And yet, they crashed out of the CT.<br /><br />Ditto Lanka with all manner of freakish bowlers.<br /><br />Long story short, if it was that easy to bowl block holers, games would not extend to beyond 5 overs.<br /><br />I would refer you to <a href="http://prempanicker.wordpress.com/2009/10/01/champions-atrophy/" rel="nofollow">this post by Prem Panicker </a> that captures the problem more succinctly.<br /><br />One of the by products of this is that we dont pick the right personnel in turn - the ones we pick are either jaded or so much in a groove that they find it difficult to alter what they are doing. But thats where the paid selection committee is expected to step in.<br /><br />And we know what their master plan for the CT was!<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06387483505008411160noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-34632883136039615682009-10-02T07:39:31.222+05:302009-10-02T07:39:31.222+05:30Homer,
I apologize for the series of posts, but I...Homer,<br /><br />I apologize for the series of posts, but I just had to make this comparison.<br /><br />Your analysis is like looking at a control chart and finding a point way out of control. Instead of reacting to it, you dismiss it as a false amarm!Knoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-78906677192258784312009-10-02T07:26:04.208+05:302009-10-02T07:26:04.208+05:30I saw your last post just now. And I agree. I have...I saw your last post just now. And I agree. I have been through the Sharjah days as well, and the late 90s where Mohanty, Kuruvilla, Harvinder Singh used to bowl for India. I agree that India are in a much better position now, and have the required talent. But are we fielding the most talented 11 in a game? I dont think so.Knoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-82770961173294332502009-10-02T07:17:42.827+05:302009-10-02T07:17:42.827+05:30Homer,
I still maintain that some of India's ...Homer,<br /><br />I still maintain that some of India's weaknesses were never brought to the fore when we were winning, particularly in the bowling department. But there were indications. Death overs bowling was dismal. And the bowlers often had the luxury of a mountain of runs to cover for their weakness or they had the better of the conditions or both. And when they didnt have the better of the conditions, they faltered.Knoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-24467032114671425402009-10-02T05:13:47.042+05:302009-10-02T05:13:47.042+05:30Bhaskar,
The thing about silver linings is that I...Bhaskar,<br /><br />The thing about silver linings is that I have lived through the regular beatings we used to get at Sharjah. And the "Noel David who" episode.<br /><br />And losing after having the South Africans a 76/6. Or allowing Ravi Bopara and Stuart Broad see England through chasing 160 odd after having them at 107/7.<br /><br />Its in the last two years or so that I have seen the emergence of genuine bowling depth in the Indian team. We have all bases covered - left arm and right arm swing, seam , leg spin, off spin and left arm orthodox too.<br /><br />And given that this is genuine talent and not some impostors who are masquerading as bowlers, there is every reason to feel enthused.<br /><br />And they are young, which means that they can only get better.<br /><br />Sure they will have off days, but for the most part there is more to like about where we are today than were we were 10 years ago.<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-43437024248133191522009-10-02T02:41:07.849+05:302009-10-02T02:41:07.849+05:30Well, We are making mountains out of molehills..
...Well, We are making mountains out of molehills..<br /><br />It was poor bowling and bad luck which cost us the Champions trophy!<br />coming to the t20 wc ..can anyone ever predict a winner in a t20 competition? honestly after 2 t20 wc's and 2 ipl's i am sure none would have got the winner right before the tournament! it's generally the underdogs who win ! i am sure they way India lost out was due to some inept batting and stupid mistakes( sending jadeja in) but still . <br /><br />we lost out beacuse of Harbhajan Singh and Ishant Sharma and some 2 crucial run outs and a 50-50 decision (read gautam,dravid and raina dismissals) ! India would have done well against Australia chasing! (if not at least would have made 260+ or there abouts)<br /><br />anyhow we have had a wonderful couple of years and have a very strong team.<br /><br />just have a look at the ICC awards .If dhoni was such a pathetic captn why would they name him captn of the Test as well as ODI teams of the year? we just missed out on this tournament! <br /><br />we have a very strong team and were badly hit by injuriesa nd luck! <br /><br />i am open to any question which says we are an ordinary team! <br /><br />and rankings are based on a teams consistency and that is the real mettle of a team and to the best of my knowledge India has only lost a test series to Sri lanka ( counting the most recent test series with a nation) and has won against all and has drawn 1-1 with south africa ! and I am sure India will win against SL at home this year (SL have never won a test match in India till now!) <br /><br />We have a great team ! It will bring us greater glories in the coming seasons! not to worry !<br /><br />Ind vs aus ODI series My prediction 5-2 India ! That will surely shut some mouths up at cricinfo!Adityahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13195962756728759123noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-31303806549774834042009-10-01T23:34:28.805+05:302009-10-01T23:34:28.805+05:30No probs , Buddy...always up for a bit of verbal w...No probs , Buddy...always up for a bit of verbal with a guy who supports the same team ! didn't find that particularly nasty anyway :-)Very tempted now to get into the bit about the Aus 7 ODI series being bigger than the CT but let's leave it , shall we - this will obviously be an impasse until kingdom come - but gotta hand it to you , you're one Silver Lining guy , wish i cud be too ! <br />:-) Cheers !Bhaskar Khaundhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15210899788967335638noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-25858089310288859942009-10-01T23:03:51.508+05:302009-10-01T23:03:51.508+05:30Bhaskar,
I do apologize for the rather nasty comm...Bhaskar,<br /><br />I do apologize for the rather nasty comment in response to your previous comment.<br /><br />That said, just about every newspaper and cricket website is making the exact same calls you say are not happening - how India has not progressed in 3 of the 4 ICC tourneys, how our bowling and batting sucks, how this exit marks the beginning of the apocalypse :).<br /><br />For mine, the 2011 WC is the only thing that matters. There is the small matter of the WC being at home and also the other small matter of correcting the performance of 2007.<br /><br />Bilateral/multilateral series matter so far as fine tuning the game plan and consolidating our standing on the ICC table. <br /><br />But is losing in a tourney in England or South Africa going to have a major bearing on the WC in the sub continent? I think not.<br /><br />I would say that the 7 ODI set against Australia is a better gauge of how far we have come and how much further we have to go to get our act together for 2011.<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-43727806190005300962009-10-01T22:56:10.299+05:302009-10-01T22:56:10.299+05:30Wasim,
Fir points.. But then, lets turn the argum...Wasim,<br /><br />Fir points.. But then, lets turn the argument - Pakistan, after scoring 300+ against India, bowled 7 no balls. And but for India's batting ineptitude, would have lost the game. <br /><br />England, defending 300+, conceded 301 odd against South Africa, with one man (Graeme Smith) scoring the bulk of the runs. Australia's bowling suffered a huge scare, courtesy of the West Indies - at 170/3 the game was pretty much wide open.<br /><br />Had the results gone the other way, what would the consensus on India's bowling ability be?<br /><br />On the flip side, India dismissed the West Indies for 129 - the lowest score WI managed to achieve in thier 3 matches :)<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-65814984878026906552009-10-01T20:49:19.720+05:302009-10-01T20:49:19.720+05:30Homer , i choose to read it today ! Btw , no one&#...Homer , i choose to read it today ! Btw , no one's saying its the end of the world. It's only a game , remember ? Nor is anybody denying India are one of the 4-5 better sides around.Even calls for MSD's exit must have been spur-of-the-moment at best...Anyway , just curious to know what you consider molehill as opposed to mountain. Clear inference is that CT 2009 is a molehill but WC 11 is a mountain. What about T20 WC 07 ? and T20EC 09 ? ..and bi lateral series..- which are mountains and which molehills ? Just curious...CheersBhaskar Khaundhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15210899788967335638noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-89151621740578190512009-10-01T19:35:14.336+05:302009-10-01T19:35:14.336+05:30I do agree with your point that the fans who are c...I do agree with your point that the fans who are calling for Dhoni's head are over reacting, exiting early from this tournament and T20 WC does not diminish their cricketing power house status but to enjoy the staus of #1 or #2 team in the world India will have to correct its bowling problems.Wasimhttp://www.cricketfiles.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-78142875138258126432009-10-01T19:31:15.919+05:302009-10-01T19:31:15.919+05:30Homer
The problem is that with the exception of Z...Homer<br /><br />The problem is that with the exception of Zaheer Khan no Indian pacer can bowl an effective yorker or a vicious bouncer, their pace at best is gentle medium pace, Ishaant showed some promise with his swing and pace but he has lost both.<br /><br /> A lot of people blame Sachin that why most of 100's were not match winning ones? It's only because India's bowling have always let down their batsmen. With a decline in Harbhajan's bowling the problem has compunded, I think other teams have worked him out.<br /><br />I agree SA and SriLanka didn't had any injured players but doesn't it make their problem more serious that other teams which were running thin on resources still managed to beat them their bench players were stronger then the regular players of these teams.Wasimhttp://www.cricketfiles.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-40893446046471287642009-10-01T18:53:38.826+05:302009-10-01T18:53:38.826+05:30K,
Its a bit of s stretch to suggest that a team ...K,<br /><br />Its a bit of s stretch to suggest that a team can hide its inability in bilateral series but spring it forth in multi lateral fora.<br /><br />So we have a finals jinx. And we cannot win multilateral tourneys. And the 2007 WC win was because no one took it seriously. And beating England 5-0 is no big deal because England are not flash. And we were lucky to win the CB series too.<br /><br />And yet we are at the top or the near top of the ICC rankings.. Which should then speak volumes about how crappy the other teams are :)<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5134440631193335724.post-45094223038033561992009-10-01T18:49:30.284+05:302009-10-01T18:49:30.284+05:30Adverbin,
But is exiting the Champions Trophy suc...Adverbin,<br /><br />But is exiting the Champions Trophy such a major catastrophe that we lose all sense of what as been achieved before and what this team is capable of?<br /><br />"My point is we fans can deny problems; but should the team/selectors/management not identify/accept/correct them?" - Sure the management needs to correct the problems. But arent the fans over reacting to what is nothing more than a minor setback?<br /><br />If we had gone all the way and won the Champs Trophy, what would it have proved? naysayers would have pointed out that since India did not play South Africa and Sri Lanka, it is not a proper assessment of where this team stands.<br /><br />Cheers,Homerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949049044524078820noreply@blogger.com