What is India doing in Zimbabwe?
the after effects of robbing singh...
is it only me or have you also noticed that since robbing singh was sacked from the job... team india has started fielding well...
fielders are attacking the ball... curbing the singles in inner circle... hitting stumps too with regularity as jadeja showed with the dismissal of ponting...
i would attribute all this to the 'after effects' of robbing singh...
Coaches, Baggage Handlers, Lies, Stats and Google!
July 31, 2009 - Paul Farbrace has announced that he will be quitting his post as Sri Lanka's assistant coach when his contract ends on August 20 to take up the position of head coach of Kent.
17 August 2009 - Sri Lanka Cricket is on the hunt for a new assistant coach to fill Paul Farbrace's position.
2nd Match: India v New Zealand at Colombo (RPS) - Sep 11, 2009 - India is in Sri Lanka for the Compaq Cup thru Sept 14th 2009
Sep 19, 2009 - India depart for South Africa for the Champions Trophy
6th Match, Group A: India v Pakistan at Centurion - Sep 26, 2009
October 6, 2009 - Robin Singh, the former India allrounder and current fielding coach, has been appointed coach of Mumbai Indians for the third season of the IPL, and former fast bowler Paras Mhambrey as his deputy.
Oct 16 2009 - Venkatesh Prasad and Robin Singh fired as coaches by the BCCI
October 23, 2009 - de Silva revealed that Venkatesh Prasad, the former India bowling coach released from that post last week, was also a contender for the post and had submitted "a strong application" but the SLC decided in favour of Law as he suited their requirements better.
Imprints of a coach
Imprint (verb) im’print - Establish or impress firmly in the mind
If we were to go by etymology, then yes they did. This is in relation to Venkatesh Prasad and Rabindra Ramnarain Singh and the demons.
Let’s get a bit practical. If etymology drove our life, the driver would be Greg Chappell. For, he did establish or impress firmly in the mind of an Indian fan !!
My view is that a coach who leaves an imprint is a bad coach… The case point is Buchanan, he left his imprint not once but twice. Once in Australia and again in Kolkota . One seems a deceptively successful example if you leave the “Maa Ki” tour aside and the other the obvious. The other is Duncan Fletcher, luckily there came a cushion called Peter Moores and a cue called KP.
Greg Chappell is folklore in India, we definitely know what imprint means.
Believe me I don’t belong to the Shane Warne school of thought. I come from a family of teachers, I broke the line for the first time in 4 generations (in recent memory). There needs to be a teacher, but I belong to the contemporary school of teaching. Yes, the teacher needs to be someone the ward could relate to and reason with… Someone who course corrects, the man in charge of the rudder.
I, for one liked those days when Bishen Bedi was the manager (a coach was called so those days) of the Indian cricket team. Surprisingly he spoke less (or there were less many TV channels) but he did a very good job. Those who speak about Robin doing a change “imprint” on the fielding would have to remember and see the batting records of Bedi and his "imprint" in that department when he was the manager.
If only coaches had a magic wand, Mahrajkumar of Vijayanagaram would have eclipsed The Don. And Lalu Prasad would have hired the best of brains.
For us Indians bad is the culmination of good and vice versa. We don’t believe in the concept of a full stop unless it is an obituary. Otherwise it is always a comma.
Manifestations of the demon
Somerset were to play the Eagles (they did yesterday), it was a crucial encounter. They needed their top order to fire, help them post a good total on board. So that their bits and pieces bowlers would step in to give them a helping hand. Even before the ink dried on the strategy map there was ink on someone’s passport - The stamp of goodbye, the mark of departure or whatever you would want to call it. The passport belonged to one Marcus Edward Trescothick, the same man who had to leave half way from a party that toured India and again in the midst of an Ashes campaign.
Marcus was (rather is) fighting demons from within, demons that wouldn’t want to see him leave the shores of England to play. After a concerted fight Marcus seemed to have managed to cage the demons during a tour of UAE early this year. He landed in India on a positive note, though he didn’t make any notable contribution, his team banked on his experience. After all he was the top dog in the last county season.
But Marcus did well to fight them, in fact he nearly vanquished them before this reappearance. Demons, they have their way.
Manoj Prabhakar said he is a glorified luggage handler. One could understand Prabhakar’s frustrations. For, in a cricket team the luggage handler is the booker… Well err… I mean the one who takes care of the travel arrangement of the touring party. I am sure Prabhakar thought he was the master Booker, every bookie’s friend and a smart cookie who tries deflecting the blame. So why someone else? (BTW, did he aim his potshots at Russell Radhakrishnan or Venky ??)
Nonsense apart, Venkatesh Prasad is probably one of the qualified coaches in India, he did well while as the coach of Karnataka. Whatever said about his speed, he was an intelligent bowler and was successful too. If he was not, any of Ashish Winston Zaidi, Dodda Ganesh, David Johnson, Abhay Kuruvilla & Paras Mahbrey would have played more tests than him. Add their numbers together it would still be lesser than Venky’s. I am sure he contributed something atleast.
He was perched on top of the open bus savoring the T20 win, he was on top of the world when some commentators called India’s bowling attack the best in the world.
But that was before the demons had their way.
Robin Singh or Robbing Singh, call him whatever. He is one of the earnest figures in Indian cricket, again one of the few qualified figures. Hardworking and sincere, that is how most of his peers describe him. I am sure Sachin Tendulkar wouldn’t have recommended his name as Mumbai Indians coach for nothing.
Sachin called him just before the demons ejected him. And then, the demons had their way.
Rahul Dravid, whatever said he definitely is an all season’s player. He is one of the most successful ODI players India has ever had, someone who brought solidity into the middle order. He has more been a silent samurai than a cricket player. For, he’s had to slay the demons all through his career.
Does anyone remember Jaywant Lele ? Rahul Dravid is not fit for ODI’s he proclaimed and had him dropped from the team. Dravid fought his way back. And then it was the Colonel’s turn, he had to stand down as captain (I thought he was a rather successful captain) and saw himself dropped from the ODI team.
And then came the bouncers, those were the demons down Rohit Sharma & Suresh Raina’s alley. They saw the resurgence of Dravid, but it was shortlived. The next place where the Indians play ODI’s is at home where it doesn’t bounce that well.
So the demons had their way.
Demons have had their way either by themselves as the Trescothick story illustrates or through a demoniac as in the case of Venky, Robin & Rahul.
Many variants of demon but their objective is the same, elimination. Raina’s, Bhajji’s and even Dhoni’s run for that amulet, the day when the demons would chase you is not too far.
Why Sidhu should be India's next fielding coach
It's not easy to create vacancy when laying off is of the essence. But BCCI manages to do it with elan.
How? Simply by laying off!
So here rolls the head of Robbing-turned-Robbed Singh and there rolls the same of country's most famous luggage-handler Venkateswara's Prasad.
To sum up the situation, there you have two ready vacancies.
Now while BCCI is free to jolt a retire Supreme Court judge out of his slumber and make him head a head-hunting panel to find the next bowling coach, I would mildly suggest that the irrepressible Navjot Singh Sidhu aka Jonty Singh for the fielding coach's job.
Dub my a loony, call me a Sidhu, but not before you listen to the arguments.
Of course the proposition is fraught with risks of hearing impairments but Sidhu's presence is guaranteed to lift the fitness and fielding levels to such a stratospheric level, from where players would simply refuse to come down.
After all, you can't go home and have your eight hours when all ringing inside your dome is something along this line:
"Oye Guru, you miss a catch and it can be catch 22."
Let me tell you, no judge or participant has survived more than two sessions in any TV shows which had Sidhu under the same roof from where plasters came off every time he laughed.
So if dropping a catch invites a one-on-one session with Sidhu, no right-thinking cricketer – I would go to the extent of including the left-thinking ilk as well – would make that fatal mistake.
Besides, Younis Khan would vouch, it pays to have MPs by your side.
Anyone listening?
Robbing Singh - prelude to a termination letter
Hello maan,
Thought we'd drop you a line while your wards dropped a few more catches.
We haven't seen any of the highly suspect methods employed by you, but we are in complete agreement that you should be taken out of your employment.
Seeing as this is the prelude to your termination letter, please help us answer a few questions. This will make your termination swift.
1) Who the f**k are you answerable to –Kirsten, India’s star players or are you Indian crickets’ KPS Gill? Bottom line, how long before you feel the pinch?
2) What does it take for a fielder to improve - Sidhu improved enough to become Jonty Singh. Do Munaf Patel and Ishant Sharma have to take another man's life to give a batsman fewer lives?
3) On a good day, India's catching is on par with the Windies’ catching on a bad day, and don't we all know where you come from maan?
4) Is the BCCI trying to makeup for you playing most of your international cricket in your twilight years?
5) Are you just one of the boys – and coach Kirsten has taken it upon himself to not only worsen the players’ fielding but your coaching too
6) Are you too polite a guy to ask Yuvi to take his vitamins and catches
7) Do the players not understand your Trinidadian accent
Good luck with your new life,
Bored Member
PS: For more lists, do drive down to Bored Member Som’s backyard, seeing as you're going to have plenty of time on your hands
For the entire Robbing Singh series, drop by here
robbing singh...?

carrying on from my post here at BCC!...can you explain mr robin singh...? in which i raised this question...during second test i think...
have you ever anticipated that dravid, sachin and even laxman are not gonna carry on for ever...
being a fielding coach can you lay claim on developing a single slip fielder in all these years...?
i think his case is a clear cut example of sitting on laurels (if any)...relaxed into warming the chair...knowing the job is unchallenged and reserved till he wishes...
we were never a brilliant fielding outfit but at least we were good catchers...more than three years of robin singh at the helm as fielding coach and we can't even claim to be good catchers now...so much for his 'achievements'...
in fact everytime ball goes in the air towards a fielder my heart misses a beat with the possibility of another catch getting grassed...and less said about slip cordon the better...
he has simply failed to inculcate 'fielding' culture in the team...even the players who were good (like yuvraj) now seems to be wanting...he has allowed them to drift away thereby failing to assert himself...
since we won't be playing tests till late this year...i think it's time to say goodbye to him for his services and look for another fielding coach who will bring some fresh perspective and intensity which is clearly lacking in our players these days...
besides the chosen one will get ample time to groom players for the next world cup as well as the challenges of tests...now that we have pronounced that we want to be numero uno...
although dhoni proudly said "we have set the benchmark"... but i firmly believe that any other team with same skill set but better fitness level would have whitewashed kiwis...and that would have been the perfect benchmark...in my opinion...
can you explain mr robin singh...?
what you have been doing these (three) years or so...?
no my question is not related to the pathetic fielding display...i am used to seeing it...
my question is related to yuvraj dropping catches at slip...and the question is...
have you ever anticipated that dravid, sachin and even laxman are not gonna carry on for ever...
being a fielding coach can you lay claim on developing a single slip fielder in all these years...?
what's the role of a fielding coach then...doing fielding drills that even boycott's mom can do...?
...and we are regressing alarmingly on that front too...
More »



